| Member Posts: 187
 Joined: Sep 2002
 
 | 
| IN THE NAME OF ALLAH THE MOST GRACIOUS THE MOST MERCIFUL 
 About four weeks ago I call Shiek Faalih to ask him
 
 about going to Bahrain and taking knowledge from Shiek
 
 Fawzee. The following is a transcript of the
 
 conversation. It is recorded.
 
 Rasheed: As-salaamu alaikum wa rahamutu ALLAHU
 Sheik Faalih: Wa laikum salaam wa rahamtu ALLAH.
 
 Rasheed: I am requesting to speak with Sheik Faalih.
 Sheik Faalih: Na'am
 
 Rasheed: Na'am, I'm sorry for disturbing you Sheik, I
 
 have one very important question if you have the time.
 
 Sheik Faalih: Na'am, please
 Rasheed: Some brothers wish to go to Bahrain and take
 
 knowledge from Sheik Fawzee Al Athari. We don't have
 
 doubt about our Shiek; but after the fitna of Abi Hasan,
 
 we are afraid to travel to any land without asking the
 
 People of Knowledge first. So is it good if I go to
 
 Bahrain and sit with him?
 
 Shiek Faalih: You can sit with him and gain knowledge
 
 from him, but he is not from the Major Scholars. Now, we
 
 are making clear for the brothers the difference between
 
 the Major Scholars and returning the affairs back to
 
 them and the students of knowledge, those that are upon
 
 good and upon the minhaj. So he (Sheik Fawzee) is upon
 
 good and upon the minhaj. You can benefit from him. He
 
 is salafi. But he is a student, he has not yet reached
 
 the level of the Major Scholars, those whom the affairs
 
 are returned to from Ahlus Sunnah. You know this, if you
 
 know this then you can get benefit from him. And if you
 
 find something that needs to be returned to the Major
 
 Scholars then return it to the Major Scholars.
 You can benefit from him, you can call him, you can read
 
 what he writes from books. He is NOT from the people of
 
 bida, he is not from those who have a deviant minhaj.
 
 But it is possible that he could make a ruling where he
 
 will not have the same understanding as the Major
 
 Scholars, those that have the precise understanding.
 This is the same speech that we have said about Ali
 
 Hasan Al Hameed, and Saleem Al Hilaali, and Abdul Malik
 
 Ar Ramadanee. It is obigatory that the brothers know the
 
 difference between the Major Sholars and the students of
 
 knowledge. So (they will not be mislead) if a students
 
 opposes the Major Scholars, especially in the affairs of
 
 minhaj, and aqeedah, and wala wa bara and things like
 
 this.
 And Fawzee Al Athari is better(ahsan hala) than those I
 
 just mentioned(ie:Ali Hasan, Saleem Al Hilaali, Abdul
 
 Malik). His condition is better, and his is better with
 
 clinging to Salafiya, better than them in minhaj.
 His minhaj is better, better than them. Na'am. Hayaka
 
 ALLAH.
 
 Rasheed: Tayib jazaka ALLAHU kharain Ya Shiek, Ya Sheik
 
 we love you for the sake of ALLAH.
 
 Sheik Faalih: He is better in minhaj than them. huh
 Rasheed: I said, we here in America love you for the
 
 sake of ALLAH
 
 Shiek Faalih: May ALLAH love you. May ALLAH guide you.
 
 {end of kalaam}
 
 Rasheed Barbee
 
 
  
			
			 | 
 |