Member
Posts: 137
Joined: Feb 2006
|
Clarification Concerning Some of Shadeed
Muhammad's False Reports and Unverified Narrations
Written by Abul-Hasan Maalik Ibn Aadam
Allaah says,
 |  | Hud (11):93 |
æóíóÇ Þóæúãö ÇÚúãóáõæÇú Úóáóì ãóßóÇäóÊößõãú Åöäøöí ÚóÇãöáñ ÓóæúÝó ÊóÚúáóãõæäó ãóä íóÃúÊöíåö ÚóÐóÇÈñ íõÎúÒöíåö æóãóäú åõæó ßóÇÐöÈñ æóÇÑúÊóÞöÈõæÇú Åöäøöí ãóÚóßõãú ÑóÞöíÈñ "And O my people! Act according to your ability and way, and I am acting (on my way). You will come to know who it is on whom descends the torment that will cover him with ignominy, and who is a liar! And watch you! Verily, I too am watching with you." |
|
|
'Abdullaah Ibnul-Mubaarak said,
| quote: |
| "If it were not for the chain of narrators, anyone could say whatever they pleased." Refer to Sharaf Ashaabul-Hadeeth (1/15) of al-Khateeb al-Baghdaadee. |
|
In his recent clarification of events, Shadeed Muhammad, may Allaah guide him, has mentioned a number of false reports and unverified narrations. Statements that mention supposed discussions and actions of which Shadeed Muhammad was not present in and are therefore second hand reports, and therefore he needs to qualify these statements and reports on reliable witnesses with his chain of narrators back to those individuals and reports. We have seen his relating false information and a blatant lie that Hasan as-Somali, 'Abdul-Ilaah, and 'Abdul-Walee Nelson went to Shaykh 'Ubayd al-Jaabiree and informed him as to his going to the cinema in Tobago.
Before mentioning the clarification of Shaykh 'Ubayd al-Jaabiree that this is an untruth that he invented upon our brothers, it should be asked of Shadeed Muhammad to name those who related this (and other unverified reports) to him and to clarify that this is inaccurate.
Shadeed said on page 7,
| quote: |
| "So Abdulilah, along with Abdul Wali Nelson from Philadelphia and Hasaan Somali, went to Sheikh Ubayd and told him that I went to the movies and apparently mentioned other things which, come to find out, were blatant lies. Sheikh Ubayd said that I should not be giving da'wah. When I spoke to Hassan Somali about the incident he said: "Wallahi Shadeed I was not there when Abdulilah asked the question!" However, he admitted that he was aware of what the sheikh said shortly thereafter (the same night)." |
|
He goes on to say,
| quote: |
| "The funny thing about all of this is that when Hassan Somali returned to America In July of 2010, he acted as if he didn?t know about the incident and definitely concealed the fact that he was there!!!" |
|
So we clearly see that even though Hasan as-Somali clarified to the brother that he was not present when the question was asked, Shadeed continued to rely upon his narration from his unnamed source. So yesterday on the 30th of July 2010CE, Hasan as-Somali contacted Shaykh 'Ubayd al-Jaabiree and the following was asked and answered:
| quote: |
"First Question: Shadeed Muhammad claimed, may Allaah guide him, in an article that he posted on the internet that the brother 'Abdul-Ilaah, the brother 'Abdul-Walee from Philadelphia, and Hasan as-Somali went to Shaykh 'Ubayd and informed him that he (i.e. Shadeed) went to the movies and he said 'that which is apparent is that they mentioned other things which were blatant lies.' What is the authenticity of these words?
Answer: In the name of Allaah and all praise is due to Allaah; and may Allaah send peace and salutations upon the Messenger, his Family and his Companions. Verily, this person called Shadeed Muhammad from America is an individual that is lost and the Muslim males and females are not advised to listen to his lectures. It has been established by the reports of trustworthy individuals that he visited Trinidad and after the lecture or classes he went to the movies. One of the people who informed us of this was our brother and companion 'Abdul-Ilaah ar-Raabih from the United Kingdom, originally from Morocco. As for you, brother Hasan, I didn?t hear anything from you about this matter." |
|
So, here for the noble reader is the testimony of the Shaykh himself verifying that this indeed was untrue. And if Shadeed did not accept the report from Hasan as-Somali, why didn?t he merely contact Shaykh 'Ubayd to ask him?
In addition to this untruth, as well as others to be clarified, on page 7, he states,
| quote: |
| "Neglecting this principle only perpetuates the fitnah that is between the brothers. The conversation I had with the brother Yusuf was confidential, at least I thought at the time. He went back to Abu Khadeejah as well as Hassan Somali in the UK and Abul Hassan Malik in the USA (may Allah preserve them) and discussed with them the conversation I had with him." |
|
Again, Shadeed's unnamed sources have given him misinformation. As he mentioned me in a list of brothers that Yusuf in Tobago supposedly contacted. I called Yusuf in Tobago yesterday on the 30th of July, 2010 and asked him to clarify this untruth in an e-mail. Here are the words taken from the correspondence:
| quote: |
| "With the Name of Allaah The Owner of All Mercy and The Bestower of Mercy. Verily All Praise belongs to Allaah and May The Eternal Peace and Blessing of Allaah be upon His Messenger Muhammad and His Family and Companions and All those who follow him precisely until the day of judgement To proceed, Allaah Ash-Shaheed as my witness, I Yusuf Diab of Muwahhideen Publications, Tobago, Trinidad & Tobago would like to clarify that I never contacted Abul Hasan Malik concerning Shadeed Muhammad?s statements about Salafi Publications, going to the movies or any other matter concerning Shadeed, as he (Shadeed) falsely claims in his article ?The Paradigm Shift of the Salafi Da?wah in the West? Abu Zaynab Yusuf ibn Abdul-Lateef Ibn Yusuf Ibn Sulaymaan Ibn Abbaas DiabMuwahhideen Publications, TobagoTrinidad & Tobago31/07/201019/08/1431" |
|
I leave the reader with a narration of 'Umar Ibnul-Khattaab related in the introduction of the Saheeh of Imam Muslim, "He will never be an Imaam from amongst us who narrates everything that he hears." May Allaah rectify our affairs. Indeed He is The All-Hearing, The All-Aware.
|
|
|
|
SunnahPublishing.Net
01-08-2010 @ 2:17 AM
